Agent Skill Architect Workflow

This skill guides you through creating high-quality Agent Skills following a proven 6-step process.

🚨 CRITICAL WORKFLOW REQUIREMENTS 🚨

Before you begin, understand these NON-NEGOTIABLE rules:

You MUST run scripts/scaffold_skill.py in Step 3.
Manual file creation is PROHIBITED. The scaffolding script ensures consistency.
You MUST use the generated templates.
After scaffolding, templates exist in references/. Use them as your foundation.
You MUST run scripts/validate_skill.py in Step 5.
Validation catches errors before they propagate.
You MUST follow all 6 steps in order.
Skipping steps leads to non-compliant or broken skills.

If you bypass scaffolding scripts, you have FAILED this workflow.

Step 1: Understanding the Skill

Before scaffolding, clearly understand how the skill will be used through concrete examples.

For New Skills:

Ask the user clarifying questions to understand:

What functionality should the skill support?
What are example queries that should trigger this skill?
What outputs or actions should result?
Are there existing workflows or tools to integrate?

Example questions:

"Can you give some examples of how this skill would be used?"
"What would a user say that should trigger this skill?"
"What existing scripts or documentation should be included?"

For Existing Skills:

If working with an existing skill, analyze:

Current SKILL.md structure and content
Existing scripts, references, and assets
What's working well vs. what needs improvement

Conclude this step when: You have a clear sense of the skill's functionality and triggering scenarios.

Step 2: Planning Reusable Contents

Analyze the concrete examples from Step 1 to identify what reusable resources would help.

⚠️ Critical Decision: Script vs. Checklist

Before planning scripts, ask: "Is this task primarily analysis or computation?"

Analysis tasks (reading, synthesizing, pattern recognition): → Use checklists or reference docs for LLM to follow → Examples: Repository analysis, code review, documentation synthesis

Computation tasks (math, APIs, precise transformations): → Use scripts for deterministic execution → Examples: Schema validation, API calls, file format conversion

Real example from this session:

❌ Initially planned analyze_repo.py script
✅ Corrected to analysis_checklist.md reference
Why: Repository analysis = LLM strength (reading, pattern detection, synthesis)

See references/BEST_PRACTICES.md §6 for detailed decision flowchart.

Ask for each example:

How would I execute this task from scratch?
What scripts, references, or assets would make this repeatable?
Is this analysis (LLM) or computation (script)?

Resource Types:

scripts/ - For deterministic operations only:

✅ Math/computation (calculations, aggregations)
✅ External interactions (API calls, database queries)
✅ Precise transformations (file format conversion, schema validation)
✅ Repetitive generation (boilerplate rendering)
❌ Analysis tasks (use checklists instead)
❌ Pattern recognition (LLM excels at this)

references/ - For LLM-driven analysis and knowledge:

✅ Checklists for systematic analysis (e.g., repository discovery)
✅ Pattern libraries (e.g., positive constraint conversions)
✅ API documentation (endpoints, parameters)
✅ Domain knowledge (company policies, industry standards)
✅ Decision trees and workflows

assets/ - For files used in output:

✅ Templates (documents, slides, boilerplate code)
✅ Images (logos, icons, diagrams)
✅ Fonts (typography files)
✅ Seed data (sample datasets, fixtures)

Output: A list of specific files to create with correct categorization (script vs reference)

Step 3: Skill Scaffolding

⚠️ MANDATORY STEP - DO NOT SKIP ⚠️

You MUST execute the scaffolding script. Manual file creation is PROHIBITED.

Command:

python3 scripts/scaffold_skill.py --name <skill-name>

Options:

Default mode: Creates SKILL.md + example files in scripts/, references/, assets/
Simple mode: Use --simple flag for minimal structure (SKILL.md only)

The script will:

✅ Validate naming conventions (lowercase, hyphens, alphanumeric)
✅ Create skill directory in .github/skills/
✅ Generate SKILL.md with structuring guidance
✅ Create example files to demonstrate resource organization

Note: The script auto-detects .github/skills from git root. Naming must match regex: ^[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*[a-z0-9]$

✅ Verification Checkpoint

After running the scaffolding script, confirm these files exist:

ls -la .github/skills/<skill-name>/

Expected output:

SKILL.md (with "Structuring This Skill" guidance section)
scripts/example.py (placeholder script)
references/example_reference.md (placeholder reference)
assets/README.md (if using default mode)

🛑 STOP CONDITIONS:

If SKILL.md does NOT exist → Scaffolding failed, do NOT proceed
If you created files manually → You have violated the workflow, DELETE and re-run script
If the script reported errors → Fix errors before proceeding to Step 4

Step 4: Content Generation

Populate the skill with actual content.

4.1: Implement Reusable Resources First

Start with scripts/, references/, and assets/ identified in Step 2.

For scripts:

Replace scripts/example.py with actual implementation
Test by running: python3 scripts/<script_name>.py
Ensure error messages are descriptive (print to stderr)

For references:

Replace references/example_reference.md with actual docs
Keep SKILL.md lean - move details here
For large files (>100 lines), add Table of Contents

For assets:

Add actual template files, images, fonts
Replace or delete assets/README.md
Use descriptive filenames

Important: Delete any example files you don't need!

4.2: Write SKILL.md Content

Follow the structuring guidance embedded in the generated SKILL.md template.

Choose your structure pattern:

Workflow-Based: Sequential processes (see references/workflows.md)
Task-Based: Tool collections with different operations
Reference/Guidelines: Standards, specifications, coding rules
Capabilities-Based: Integrated systems with multiple features

Key elements:

Frontmatter (YAML):
- name: Must match directory name exactly
- description: High-entropy, keyword-rich, 3rd person
  - Include WHEN to use this skill (triggers)
  - Include WHAT the skill does (capabilities)
  - Example: "Processes PDF documents for form filling, text extraction, and merging. Use when working with PDF files or when user requests document manipulation tasks."
Body (Markdown):
- Use imperative/infinitive form ("Run the script", not "You should run")
- Reference scripts/references explicitly by path
- Consult references/BEST_PRACTICES.md for the "Freedom Scale"
- Consult references/output-patterns.md for output formatting

Delete the "Structuring This Skill" section when done - it's guidance only!

4.3: Design Patterns

For multi-step processes: See references/workflows.md

Sequential workflows (step 1 → step 2 → step 3)
Conditional workflows (if/then branching)
Iterative workflows (refinement loops)

For consistent outputs: See references/output-patterns.md

Strict templates (non-negotiable formats)
Flexible guidance (adaptable structure)
Examples-based (show don't tell)
Validation checklists (quality requirements)

Step 5: Validation

⚠️ MANDATORY STEP - DO NOT SKIP ⚠️

Run the validation script to ensure specification compliance.

Command:

python3 scripts/validate_skill.py --path <path-to-skill-root>

Example:

python3 scripts/validate_skill.py --path .github/skills/diagnose-ci-failure

What it checks:

✅ Directory naming regex (^[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*[a-z0-9]$)
✅ SKILL.md exists
✅ YAML frontmatter has required fields (name, description)
✅ Name in YAML matches directory name
⚠️ Advisory: Presence of references/ and scripts/ (warnings only)

If validation fails:

Read the error output carefully
Fix critical violations immediately
Warnings are informational (acceptable for simple skills)

When valid: Proceed to testing!

✅ Post-Validation Checklist

Before proceeding to Step 6, confirm:

Workflow Compliance:

I RAN scripts/scaffold_skill.py (Step 3)
I USED the generated templates from scaffolding
I CONSULTED references/TEMPLATES.md and references/BEST_PRACTICES.md (Step 4)
I RAN scripts/validate_skill.py (Step 5)
Validation script reported SUCCESS (no critical errors)

Content Quality:

YAML frontmatter includes name and description
Description is high-entropy and keyword-rich
No "Structuring This Skill" guidance section remains in SKILL.md
Example files (example.py, example_reference.md) are deleted or replaced
Scripts are in scripts/, references in references/, templates in assets/

🛑 STOP CONDITION: If you did NOT run the scaffolding script or manually created files, STOP and re-do from Step 3.

Step 6: Testing and Iteration

After creating the skill, test and refine based on real usage.

Testing Workflow:

Test with real examples from Step 1
- Does the skill trigger on expected queries?
- Do scripts execute without errors?
- Is output quality acceptable?
Identify friction points:
- Are instructions clear enough?
- Are there missing scripts or references?
- Is context loaded efficiently?
Iterate on improvements:
- Update SKILL.md for clarity
- Add missing examples or edge cases
- Optimize script error handling
- Split large references if needed (progressive disclosure)
Re-validate after changes

Common Iteration Patterns:

Problem: Skill isn't triggering when expected Solution: Enhance description with more keywords and trigger scenarios

Problem: Agent struggles with workflow steps Solution: Add decision tree or flowchart; consult references/workflows.md

Problem: Context feels bloated Solution: Move content from SKILL.md to references/; add grep hints

Problem: Scripts fail in edge cases Solution: Add error handling; print descriptive messages to stderr

Problem: Output quality inconsistent Solution: Add templates or validation checklist; see references/output-patterns.md

When to Stop Iterating:

✅ Skill triggers reliably on target queries
✅ Workflows execute without confusion
✅ Output quality meets requirements
✅ No critical errors in testing

Knowledge Retrieval

If questions arise during skill creation:

Specification questions (naming, structure, required files): → Read references/SPECIFICATION.md

Best practices (context economy, freedom scale, anti-patterns): → Read references/BEST_PRACTICES.md

Templates and examples (frontmatter, structure patterns): → Read references/TEMPLATES.md

Workflow design (sequential, conditional, iterative): → Read references/workflows.md

Output formatting (templates, examples, validation): → Read references/output-patterns.md

Do not hallucinate answers. Always consult the authoritative sources.

generate-agent-skills

Agent Skill Architect Workflow

🚨 CRITICAL WORKFLOW REQUIREMENTS 🚨

Step 1: Understanding the Skill

For New Skills:

For Existing Skills:

Step 2: Planning Reusable Contents

⚠️ Critical Decision: Script vs. Checklist

Ask for each example:

Resource Types:

Step 3: Skill Scaffolding

Command:

Options:

✅ Verification Checkpoint

Step 4: Content Generation

4.1: Implement Reusable Resources First

4.2: Write SKILL.md Content

4.3: Design Patterns

Step 5: Validation

Command:

What it checks:

✅ Post-Validation Checklist

Step 6: Testing and Iteration

Testing Workflow:

Common Iteration Patterns:

When to Stop Iterating:

Knowledge Retrieval