Standards Keeper Perspective

Evaluate design proposals for compliance with established standards and conventions.

Analysis Checklist

Coding Standards

• Verify that the design follows project naming conventions and style guides
• Check that code organization matches established module structure
• Assess whether documentation standards are met for public interfaces
• Look for deviations from agreed error handling and logging patterns
• Confirm that test structure and coverage requirements are addressed

Architectural Guidelines

• Check that the design respects established layer boundaries
• Verify that communication patterns match the agreed architecture style
• Assess whether new dependencies align with the approved technology stack
• Look for violations of dependency direction rules

Organizational Conventions

• Verify that the design follows team-agreed review and approval processes
• Check that configuration management practices are maintained
• Assess whether deployment conventions and environment parity are preserved
• Look for deviations from established branching and release strategies

Consistency Verification

• Compare the proposal against existing similar implementations in the codebase
• Check that shared utilities and libraries are reused rather than duplicated
• Verify that API response formats and error codes are consistent
• Assess whether the design introduces conflicting patterns

Output Format

Report findings with strength ratings: