doc-adr-audit

Purpose

Run a single ADR audit workflow that executes:

1. doc-adr-validator (structural/schema gate)
2. doc-adr-reviewer (semantic/content quality gate)

Then emit one combined report optimized for doc-adr-fixer input.

Layer: 5 (ADR Quality Gate Wrapper)

Upstream: ADR file(s)

Downstream:

• Combined Audit Report: ADR-NN.A_audit_report_vNNN.md
• Optional Fix Cycle trigger for doc-adr-fixer

---

Why This Skill Exists

Use this wrapper to avoid user confusion between validator and reviewer while preserving separation of concerns.

Concern	Owner Skill
Schema/template compliance	doc-adr-validator
Content quality and decision completeness	doc-adr-reviewer
Single user-facing audit command	doc-adr-audit

---

When to Use

Use doc-adr-audit when:

• You want one command for ADR quality checks
• You need a combined report for doc-adr-fixer
• You are running QA before SYS generation

Do NOT use when:

• ADR does not exist (use doc-adr / doc-adr-autopilot generation first)
• You only need one specific check domain (use validator or reviewer directly)

---

Execution Contract

Input

• ADR path (docs/05_ADR/ADR-NN_*/...)
• Optional: threshold (default review threshold: 90)

Sequence (Mandatory)

1) Run doc-adr-validator
2) Run doc-adr-reviewer
3) Normalize and merge findings
4) Write ADR-NN.A_audit_report_vNNN.md
5) If auto-fixable findings exist, hand off to doc-adr-fixer

Combined Status Rules

• PASS: Validator PASS AND Reviewer score >= threshold AND no blocking issues
• FAIL: Validator FAIL OR Reviewer score < threshold OR blocking/manual-required issues present

---

Combined Report Format (for doc-adr-fixer)

Output file: ADR-NN.A_audit_report_vNNN.md

Required sections:

1. ## Summary
   • ADR ID, timestamp (EST), overall status
   • Validator status, reviewer score
2. ## Score Calculation (Deduction-Based)
   • Formula: 100 - total_deductions
   • Threshold comparison (>=90 pass gate)
3. ## Validator Findings
   • List by severity/code
4. ## Reviewer Findings
   • List by severity/code
5. ## Coverage Findings
   • Decision completeness summary
   • Architecture flow/diagram coverage summary
   • Traceability/tag coverage summary
6. ## Fix Queue for doc-adr-fixer
   • auto_fixable
   • manual_required
   • blocked
7. ## Recommended Next Step
   • run doc-adr-fixer
   • or manual update required

Fix Queue Normalization

Each finding MUST include:

• source: validator | reviewer
• code: issue code
• severity: error|warning|info
• file: relative path
• section: heading/anchor if known
• action_hint: short imperative guidance
• confidence: high|medium|manual-required

---

Hand-off Contract to doc-adr-fixer

doc-adr-fixer MUST accept combined audit report as equivalent upstream input:

• ADR-NN.A_audit_report_vNNN.md (preferred)
• ADR-NN.R_review_report_vNNN.md (legacy compatibility)

Precedence rule:

1. Select newest timestamp.
2. If timestamps are equal, prefer .A_audit_report over .R_review_report.

---

Example Invocation

/doc-adr-audit docs/05_ADR/ADR-01_f1_iam/

Expected outcome:

1. validator runs
2. reviewer runs
3. combined audit report generated
4. fixer can execute directly from combined report

---

Version History

Version	Date	Changes
1.0	2026-02-27	Initial ADR audit wrapper; validator→reviewer orchestration; combined report contract for fixer with .A_ preferred and .R_ legacy compatibility

Implementation Plan Consistency (IPLAN-004)

• Treat plan-derived outputs as valid source mode and verify intent preservation from implementation plan scope/objectives.
• Validate upstream autopilot precedence assumption: --iplan > --ref > --prompt.
• Flag objective/scope conflicts between plan context and artifact output as blocking issues requiring clarification.
• Do not introduce legacy fallback paths such as docs-v2.0/00_REF.