Neverthrow Exception Wrapping

Goal

Capture recoverable exceptions with neverthrow helpers instead of ad hoc try/catch.

This skill governs exception capture only. If the task also changes public return signatures, use neverthrow-return-types alongside this skill.

Detect Exception Sources

1. Identify where failures currently enter the code.

   • Look for hand-written try/catch, .catch(...) wrappers used only for conversion, direct calls to known throwing APIs, and promise-returning functions that may reject.
   • Check third-party libraries, parsers, database clients, network clients, file-system helpers, schema validators, and serialization code.

2. Distinguish the failure shape before choosing a wrapper.

   • Use the synchronous path when the operation may throw before returning a value.
   • Use the promise-function path when the operation returns a promise but may still throw before that promise exists.
   • Use the promise-instance path when you already have a PromiseLike value in hand.

3. Do not wrap APIs that already return Result or ResultAsync.

   • Compose them directly with map, mapErr, andThen, asyncAndThen, or orElse.

Choose the Wrapper

1. Use Result.fromThrowable or fromThrowable for synchronous throwing functions.

   • Always pass an error mapper so the Err side has a known type.

2. Use ResultAsync.fromThrowable for promise-returning functions that can throw before returning or fail during async execution.

   • Prefer this over ResultAsync.fromPromise(fn(...), ...) when the function call itself might throw.

3. Use ResultAsync.fromPromise or fromPromise when you already have a PromiseLike value.

   • Map rejected values into a concrete error type immediately.

4. Reuse narrow mapper functions when the same error shape appears repeatedly.

   • Prefer stable domain errors over unknown, any, and generic strings.

Avoid try/catch by Default

1. Do not add new hand-written try/catch blocks when a neverthrow helper fits the job.

   • Extract the risky operation into a function if needed and wrap that function.

2. Keep try/catch only when the surrounding construct truly requires it.

   • Examples include cleanup flows that need finally, framework boundaries that must intercept and translate exceptions, or language constructs that cannot be expressed cleanly with wrapper helpers alone.

3. If try/catch remains necessary, keep it at the narrowest boundary.

   • Convert the caught value into Err or the required framework-native response immediately.
   • Do not let the caught value flow through the codebase as untyped unknown.

Implementation Rules

1. Wrap once near the source of the throwable or rejecting operation.

   • Avoid nested wrappers around the same operation.

2. Keep error mapping explicit.

   • Prefer mapper functions that preserve useful context such as operation name, input identifiers, or upstream status codes when the local style allows it.

3. Replace conversion-only .catch(...) chains when neverthrow provides a clearer wrapper.

   • Do not simulate ResultAsync manually with Promise.resolve, Promise.reject, or custom wrapper objects.

Example Patterns

const parseConfig = Result.fromThrowable(
  JSON.parse,
  (error) => ({ type: 'ConfigParseError', cause: error }),
)

const fetchUser = ResultAsync.fromThrowable(
  apiClient.getUser,
  (error) => ({ type: 'UserFetchError', cause: error }),
)

function readBody(): ResultAsync<RequestBody, BodyReadError> {
  return ResultAsync.fromPromise(request.json(), toBodyReadError)
}

Validate Before Finishing

1. Verify new or edited failure capture uses neverthrow helpers where applicable.
2. Verify each wrapper choice matches the real failure shape: synchronous throw, promise-returning function, or existing promise.
3. Verify all error mappers produce explicit error types.
4. Verify any remaining try/catch block is documented by a real constraint instead of habit.
5. Run the normal local validation for the stack when it is safe and in scope, such as tests, linting, or type checks.

Report the Outcome

When finishing the task:

• State which throwing or rejecting operations were wrapped.
• State which neverthrow helper was used and why.
• State any remaining try/catch blocks and why they were unavoidable.
• State how caught or rejected values are mapped into explicit error types.