address-pr-comments

User request: $ARGUMENTS

If no PR specified: Detect PR from current branch. If detection fails, report and stop.

Default scope: All unresolved comments on the PR.

Goal

Classify all unresolved PR comments against false positive criteria, report triage findings, then fix actionable items with user confirmation per fix.

False Positive Detection

Type	Detection Signal
Outdated	Suggested change already exists in code; commit history shows it was addressed
Misread code	Comment's premise contradicts what code actually does
Wrong context	Comment references behavior/variables not present in the target code
Style preference	No functional or readability improvement—evaluate substance, not reviewer's tone. Naming changes that aid comprehension are actionable, not style preference
Resolved in thread	Reply discussion shows issue was already addressed or withdrawn

Classification:

• Strong false-positive signal → false-positive
• Real issue with clear fix → actionable
• Unclear validity → uncertain (report, don't fix)

Output

Triage report: Classification, reasoning, and summary counts for each comment. Format flexibly based on volume.

Per-fix flow: For each actionable item, show original comment and proposed change, then ask user to confirm with these options:

1. Fix + resolve thread (recommended) — apply fix, resolve the PR comment thread
2. Fix only — apply fix, leave thread unresolved
3. Skip — don't apply this fix

Completion summary: After all items processed, summarize actions taken (fixes applied, false positives skipped, uncertain items flagged).

Constraints

Constraint	Enforcement
Verify before classifying	Read actual code and reply threads; never classify from comment text alone
Conservative on fixes	Uncertain → report only
Explain rejections	Every false-positive needs reasoning
Per-fix confirmation	User confirms each fix individually
Resolve only when chosen	Only resolve threads or reply to comments when user selects "Fix + resolve"