Deliberation, Debate & Red Teaming

Workflow

Copy this checklist and track your progress:

Deliberation & Red Teaming Progress:
- [ ] Step 1: Define the proposal and stakes
- [ ] Step 2: Assign adversarial roles
- [ ] Step 3: Generate critiques and challenges
- [ ] Step 4: Synthesize findings and prioritize risks
- [ ] Step 5: Recommend mitigations and revisions

Step 1: Define the proposal and stakes

Ask user for the plan/decision to evaluate (specific proposal, not vague idea), stakes (what happens if this fails), current confidence level (how certain are they), and deadline (when must decision be made). Understanding stakes helps calibrate critique intensity. See Scoping Questions.