idea-validation
Installation
SKILL.md
研究假說驗證與可行性評估技能
純指令技能。LLM 醫學知識 + compare_with_literature, list_saved_references, search_local_references, validate_concept。
觸發:hypothesis、假說、PICO、feasibility、可行性、testable、研究計畫評估
Framework 1: Hypothesis Validation
Step 1: PICO 分析
| Component | 偵測重點 |
|---|---|
| Population | patients, subjects, ICU, surgical... |
| Intervention | treatment, therapy, drug, procedure... |
| Comparison | versus, vs, placebo, standard, control... |
| Outcome | mortality, survival, recovery, score, rate... |
Step 2: Testability
- Directional — higher/lower/better/worse/reduce? ✅ vs 只有描述性 ❌
- Comparison — significantly/compared/than? ✅ vs 缺基準 ❌
- Type — Null (no difference) vs Alternative (有方向)
- Specificity — <10 words 太模糊, 10-50 適當, >50 過複雜
Step 3: Study Type Recommendation
| 假說特徵 | 建議設計 |
|---|---|
| effect/efficacy/treatment | RCT or Cohort |
| risk factor/association | Cohort or Case-Control |
| prevalence/frequency | Cross-Sectional |
Framework 2: Feasibility Assessment
Sample Size Quick Check
| 類型 | 注意 |
|---|---|
| N ≤ 10 | Case report/series |
| N < 30 RCT | Pilot or crossover |
| N ≥ 100 | 大多設計合理 |
Timeline by Study Type
| 類型 | IRB | 主要工作 | 分析寫作 |
|---|---|---|---|
| RCT | 2 mo | 招募+收案 ÷3 | ÷4 |
| Retrospective | 1 mo | 資料萃取 2 mo | ÷2 |
| SR | 1 mo (protocol) | 搜尋+篩選 ÷3 | ÷3 |
Feasibility Checklist (17 items, 5 categories)
| Category | Critical Items | High Items |
|---|---|---|
| Data & Sample | 資料可及、樣本可達 | 納排標準 |
| Ethics | IRB plan、informed consent | privacy |
| Resources | — | funding, timeline, team, equipment |
| Methodology | primary outcome | stat plan, validated tools, confounders |
| Publication | — | target journal, reporting guideline, novelty |
All Critical items must be ✅ before proceeding.
使用原則
- PICO 分析用語意理解,非關鍵字匹配
- 可行性評估寧可保守
- 文獻比較用
compare_with_literatureMCP tool
Related skills
More from u9401066/med-paper-assistant
draft-writing
|
29literature-review
系統性文獻搜尋、篩選、下載、整理。觸發:文獻回顧、找論文、搜尋文獻、systematic review、literature search、PubMed、找文章、搜paper、review、reference、citation、引用、參考文獻、背景調查、background。
29roadmap-updater
更新 ROADMAP.md 狀態。觸發:roadmap、路線、規劃、里程碑。
25project-management
|
24memory-updater
更新 Memory Bank 檔案。觸發:memory、記憶、進度、存檔、sync、做到哪。
23readme-updater
更新 README.md。觸發:readme、說明、文檔、怎麼用、安裝說明。
23